Football Manager 2012

5 Star Coaching Formula

March 03, 2009 - 05:01am
DDM = Determination + Discipline + Motivating

[size=3]Strength and Aerobics[/size]

Fitness * 9 + DDM * 2
>= 270 -> 7
>= 240 -> 6
>= 210 -> 5

[size=3]Goalkeeper[/size]

Goalkeeping * 2 + DDM
>=90 -> 7
>=80 -> 6
>=70 -> 5

[size=3]Tactics[/size]

Tactics * 2 + DDM
>=90 -> 7
>=80 -> 6
>=70 -> 5

[size=3]Ball Control[/size]

Technique * 6 + Mental * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5

[size=3]Defense[/size]

Defense * 8 + (Tactics + DDM) * 3
>=360 -> 7
>=320 -> 6
>=280 -> 5

[size=3]Attack[/size]

Attacking * 6 + Tactics * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5

[size=3]Shooting[/size]

Technique * 6 + Attacking * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5

[size=3]Set Pieces[/size]

(Attacking + Mental + Technique) * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5



Examples:

strength, aerobics
fit 20 + ddm>= 45 =7
fit 19 + ddm>= 50 =7
fit 18 + ddm>= 54 =7
fit 17 + ddm>= 59 =7

goalkeeper
gkp 20 + ddm>= 50 =7
gkp 19 + ddm>= 52 =7
gkp 18 + ddm>= 54 =7
gkp 17 + ddm>= 56 =7
gkp 16 + ddm>= 58 =7
gkp 15 + ddm>= 60 =7

tactics
tac 20 + ddm>= 50 =7
tac 19 + ddm>= 52 =7
tac 18 + ddm>= 54 =7
tac 17 + ddm>= 56 =7
tac 16 + ddm>= 58 =7
tac 15 + ddm>= 60 =7

defense
def 20 + (tac+ ddm)>=67 =7
def 19 + (tac+ ddm)>=70 =7
def 18 + (tac+ ddm)>=72 =7
def 17 + (tac+ ddm)>=75 =7
def 16 + (tac+ ddm)>=78 =7
def 15 + (tac+ ddm)>=80 =7

Example

Some people have difficulty understanding the way I presented it, so here's an example:

Open Meulensteen in the data editor:
det=18 dis=18 mot=18
ddm=18+18+18=54
tac=15
att=18
def=12

Tactics Rating:
15 *2 + 54 = 84 -> 6 star

Attack Rating:
18 *6 + 15 * 3 + 54 *2 = 261 -> 6 star

Defense Rating:
12 * 8 + (15 + 54) * 3 = 303 -> 5 star

[Courtesy of AJetsOf from SI Forums]
March 04, 2009 - 04:36pm
Are there any coaches out there that are 7 stars? I can't find many.

Post them all here.
March 04, 2009 - 04:45pm
I love you.
March 04, 2009 - 05:18pm
Stuart Naylor is a 7 Star Goalkeeping Coach.

I'll be on the lookout for more.
March 04, 2009 - 05:20pm
Hate this new formula, confusing to me lol
March 05, 2009 - 06:07pm
crap, i cant find any 7 star coaches. if some1 finds a few please tell
March 05, 2009 - 06:16pm
7 star coaches will be pretty rare now.
March 06, 2009 - 05:57pm
Thought I'd share some that are in my team:

7 star:
Roberto Bocchino (Aerobic or Strength)

6 star:
Ivan Carminati (Aerobic or Strength)
Massimiliano Favo (Tactics)
Inaki Bergara (Defending)
Tosh Farrell (Shooting)


My others are 5 star, not as hard to find as 6 or 7... I don't think there are 7 star ones for some of them :D (unless some regens pop up...)
March 07, 2009 - 02:44pm
Future coaches such as ex players might be great coaches.
March 07, 2009 - 03:44pm
[quote name='metlika' post='936538' date='Mar 7 2009, 10:44 PM']Future coaches such as ex players might be great coaches.[/quote]

Any coach whose the best for setpieces ?
March 07, 2009 - 04:57pm
that new formula is too confusing for me, thanks to you guys who have posted their 6 and 7 star coaches :D
March 07, 2009 - 05:09pm
Couple more:

6 star
Laurent Chatrefoux (Goalkeeping)
Oleg Luzhnyi (Set-Pieces) --- he's an asst. manager so you either have to get him as that (he seems pretty good for an asst. manager) or offer him a ridiculously high wage as a coach.
March 08, 2009 - 07:50pm
Few I've found...

Kevin Hitchcock - 7 star Goalkeeping - Man City
David Court - 6 star Defending - Arsenal
Stefano Rapetti - 6 star Aerobic & Strength - Inter
Geovanni Petralia - 6 star Aerobic & Strength - Udinese
Tony Colbert - 6 star Aerobic & Strength - Arsenal
March 08, 2009 - 10:07pm
I'll list some of the coaches I already had...

Pako Ayestaran (6 star fitness)
Franco Baldini (6 star ball control & tactics)
Chinnici (6 star ball control & shooting) - I can't remember his first name :P
Fabio Mahseredjian (6 stars for everything except GK)
Ricardo Moniz (6 star ball control & shooting)
Adam Owen (6 star fitness)
Andres Palop (6 star fitness)
Vincenzo Pincolini (6 star fitness)
Vito Scala (6 star fitness)
Andre Vilas Boas (6 star tactics, ball control, attacking, shooting & set pieces)
March 08, 2009 - 10:43pm
A few other 6 star coaches I found:

Alan Kernaghan (defending)
Ricardo Cruz (goalkeeping)
Paolo Paixao (fitness)
Paco Herrera (tactics & defending)
Pat Jennings (goalkeeping)
March 10, 2009 - 06:37pm
Eric Steele - 7 star coach for Goalkeeping (originally at Man Utd).
Brian McClair - 6 star coach for Attacking (originally at Man Utd).
March 10, 2009 - 07:11pm
Thanks guys for all the findin keep them comin :thup:
March 16, 2009 - 12:02am
Inaki Bergera - 6 star goal keeping and defending
Fernando Moraes - 7 Star Goal Keeping
Massimiliano Favo - 6 Star Tactics
Gary Anderson - 6 Star Fitness
March 17, 2009 - 02:34pm
Ricardo Moniz should be 7 stars for attacking.shooting or set piece...
Fausto Salsano 7 stars for attacking..
March 21, 2009 - 01:27pm
Can someone explain this formula to me :paranoid: :paranoid:


I understand it now i read the whole thing.