March 03, 2009 - 05:01am
Staff
Comments:
66
Date Joined:
02 Apr 2007
Last Active:
25 Oct 2014
DDM = Determination + Discipline + Motivating

[size=3]Strength and Aerobics[/size]

Fitness * 9 + DDM * 2
>= 270 -> 7
>= 240 -> 6
>= 210 -> 5

[size=3]Goalkeeper[/size]

Goalkeeping * 2 + DDM
>=90 -> 7
>=80 -> 6
>=70 -> 5

[size=3]Tactics[/size]

Tactics * 2 + DDM
>=90 -> 7
>=80 -> 6
>=70 -> 5

[size=3]Ball Control[/size]

Technique * 6 + Mental * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5

[size=3]Defense[/size]

Defense * 8 + (Tactics + DDM) * 3
>=360 -> 7
>=320 -> 6
>=280 -> 5

[size=3]Attack[/size]

Attacking * 6 + Tactics * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5

[size=3]Shooting[/size]

Technique * 6 + Attacking * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5

[size=3]Set Pieces[/size]

(Attacking + Mental + Technique) * 3 + DDM * 2
>=270 -> 7
>=240 -> 6
>=210 -> 5



Examples:

strength, aerobics
fit 20 + ddm>= 45 =7
fit 19 + ddm>= 50 =7
fit 18 + ddm>= 54 =7
fit 17 + ddm>= 59 =7

goalkeeper
gkp 20 + ddm>= 50 =7
gkp 19 + ddm>= 52 =7
gkp 18 + ddm>= 54 =7
gkp 17 + ddm>= 56 =7
gkp 16 + ddm>= 58 =7
gkp 15 + ddm>= 60 =7

tactics
tac 20 + ddm>= 50 =7
tac 19 + ddm>= 52 =7
tac 18 + ddm>= 54 =7
tac 17 + ddm>= 56 =7
tac 16 + ddm>= 58 =7
tac 15 + ddm>= 60 =7

defense
def 20 + (tac+ ddm)>=67 =7
def 19 + (tac+ ddm)>=70 =7
def 18 + (tac+ ddm)>=72 =7
def 17 + (tac+ ddm)>=75 =7
def 16 + (tac+ ddm)>=78 =7
def 15 + (tac+ ddm)>=80 =7

Example

Some people have difficulty understanding the way I presented it, so here's an example:

Open Meulensteen in the data editor:
det=18 dis=18 mot=18
ddm=18+18+18=54
tac=15
att=18
def=12

Tactics Rating:
15 *2 + 54 = 84 -> 6 star

Attack Rating:
18 *6 + 15 * 3 + 54 *2 = 261 -> 6 star

Defense Rating:
12 * 8 + (15 + 54) * 3 = 303 -> 5 star

[Courtesy of AJetsOf from SI Forums]
March 04, 2009 - 04:36pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
25 Jul 2006
Last Active:
19 Apr 2012
Are there any coaches out there that are 7 stars? I can't find many.

Post them all here.
March 04, 2009 - 04:45pm
Comments:
484
Date Joined:
20 Aug 2007
Last Active:
05 Oct 2014
I love you.
March 04, 2009 - 05:18pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
16 Jun 2006
Last Active:
29 Sep 2013
Stuart Naylor is a 7 Star Goalkeeping Coach.

I'll be on the lookout for more.
March 04, 2009 - 05:20pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
24 Jan 2007
Last Active:
02 Jul 2014
Hate this new formula, confusing to me lol
March 05, 2009 - 06:07pm
Premium Member
Comments:
3
Date Joined:
29 May 2007
Last Active:
23 Oct 2014
crap, i cant find any 7 star coaches. if some1 finds a few please tell
March 05, 2009 - 06:16pm
Comments:
61
Date Joined:
06 May 2006
Last Active:
05 Sep 2014
7 star coaches will be pretty rare now.
March 06, 2009 - 05:57pm
Comments:
61
Date Joined:
06 May 2006
Last Active:
05 Sep 2014
Thought I'd share some that are in my team:

7 star:
Roberto Bocchino (Aerobic or Strength)

6 star:
Ivan Carminati (Aerobic or Strength)
Massimiliano Favo (Tactics)
Inaki Bergara (Defending)
Tosh Farrell (Shooting)


My others are 5 star, not as hard to find as 6 or 7... I don't think there are 7 star ones for some of them :D (unless some regens pop up...)
March 07, 2009 - 02:44pm
Premium Member
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
13 Dec 2006
Last Active:
25 Oct 2014
Future coaches such as ex players might be great coaches.
March 07, 2009 - 03:44pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
06 Mar 2009
Last Active:
01 Nov 2012
[quote name='metlika' post='936538' date='Mar 7 2009, 10:44 PM']Future coaches such as ex players might be great coaches.[/quote]

Any coach whose the best for setpieces ?
March 07, 2009 - 04:57pm
Premium Member
Comments:
9
Date Joined:
21 May 2008
Last Active:
02 Jan 2014
that new formula is too confusing for me, thanks to you guys who have posted their 6 and 7 star coaches :D
March 07, 2009 - 05:09pm
Comments:
61
Date Joined:
06 May 2006
Last Active:
05 Sep 2014
Couple more:

6 star
Laurent Chatrefoux (Goalkeeping)
Oleg Luzhnyi (Set-Pieces) --- he's an asst. manager so you either have to get him as that (he seems pretty good for an asst. manager) or offer him a ridiculously high wage as a coach.
March 08, 2009 - 07:50pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
08 Mar 2009
Last Active:
08 Mar 2009
Few I've found...

Kevin Hitchcock - 7 star Goalkeeping - Man City
David Court - 6 star Defending - Arsenal
Stefano Rapetti - 6 star Aerobic & Strength - Inter
Geovanni Petralia - 6 star Aerobic & Strength - Udinese
Tony Colbert - 6 star Aerobic & Strength - Arsenal
March 08, 2009 - 10:07pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
06 Nov 2007
Last Active:
23 Nov 2013
I'll list some of the coaches I already had...

Pako Ayestaran (6 star fitness)
Franco Baldini (6 star ball control & tactics)
Chinnici (6 star ball control & shooting) - I can't remember his first name :P
Fabio Mahseredjian (6 stars for everything except GK)
Ricardo Moniz (6 star ball control & shooting)
Adam Owen (6 star fitness)
Andres Palop (6 star fitness)
Vincenzo Pincolini (6 star fitness)
Vito Scala (6 star fitness)
Andre Vilas Boas (6 star tactics, ball control, attacking, shooting & set pieces)
March 08, 2009 - 10:43pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
06 Nov 2007
Last Active:
23 Nov 2013
A few other 6 star coaches I found:

Alan Kernaghan (defending)
Ricardo Cruz (goalkeeping)
Paolo Paixao (fitness)
Paco Herrera (tactics & defending)
Pat Jennings (goalkeeping)
March 10, 2009 - 06:37pm
Comments:
61
Date Joined:
06 May 2006
Last Active:
05 Sep 2014
Eric Steele - 7 star coach for Goalkeeping (originally at Man Utd).
Brian McClair - 6 star coach for Attacking (originally at Man Utd).
March 10, 2009 - 07:11pm
Comments:
31
Date Joined:
24 Jan 2008
Last Active:
30 Sep 2014
Thanks guys for all the findin keep them comin :thup:
March 16, 2009 - 12:02am
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
26 Dec 2007
Last Active:
16 Oct 2013
Inaki Bergera - 6 star goal keeping and defending
Fernando Moraes - 7 Star Goal Keeping
Massimiliano Favo - 6 Star Tactics
Gary Anderson - 6 Star Fitness
March 17, 2009 - 02:34pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
18 Jan 2009
Last Active:
01 Sep 2014
Ricardo Moniz should be 7 stars for attacking.shooting or set piece...
Fausto Salsano 7 stars for attacking..
March 21, 2009 - 01:27pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
25 Nov 2008
Last Active:
10 Mar 2013
Can someone explain this formula to me :paranoid: :paranoid:


I understand it now i read the whole thing.
March 28, 2009 - 01:33am
Comments:
6
Date Joined:
14 Nov 2008
Last Active:
01 Oct 2014
There is an excel worksheet for calculating coach stars

download coach stars

Someone know how to explain as it works?
March 30, 2009 - 06:25pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
30 Mar 2009
Last Active:
31 Mar 2009
ok i dont know
March 30, 2009 - 08:40pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
23 May 2008
Last Active:
05 Dec 2013
Lorenzo Buenaventura, 6 stars for aerobic
April 10, 2009 - 05:45pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
10 Oct 2007
Last Active:
17 Dec 2013
[quote name='Southy' post='934055' date='Mar 4 2009, 06:18 PM']Stuart Naylor is a 7 Star Goalkeeping Coach.

I'll be on the lookout for more.[/quote]

Stuart Naylor is a 6 Star GK Coach

19*2 = 38 + 20 + 12 + 15 =85 < 90 (;


and I'm sorry but I can't see where Franco Baldini is a 6 Star Coach for Ball Control and Tactics - he ain't even 5 Star for me


..and I have to say that the coaches from Liverpool are unbelievable bad.
May 03, 2009 - 11:42am
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
28 Mar 2009
Last Active:
15 Aug 2011
Can anybody give me more examples? Cuz I can't find 'em...;)Thanks.
May 04, 2009 - 04:56pm
Premium Member
Comments:
718
Date Joined:
07 May 2006
Last Active:
07 Oct 2014
[font="Franklin Gothic Medium"]Ally McCoist is a 6 star Attacking coach.[/font]
June 18, 2009 - 05:45pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
26 Oct 2008
Last Active:
25 Oct 2014
[quote name='clindfield' post='961173' date='Apr 10 2009, 04:45 PM']Stuart Naylor is a 6 Star GK Coach

19*2 = 38 + 20 + 12 + 15 =85 < 90 (;[/quote]

In that case his attributes must vary from game to game as he is a 7 star GK couch at my Inter Team
June 22, 2009 - 04:02pm
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
22 Jul 2008
Last Active:
05 Apr 2011
Thank you! That's what i've been looking for.
July 04, 2009 - 01:17am
Comments:
0
Date Joined:
22 Jul 2008
Last Active:
05 Apr 2011
I think you should make a formula for the youth team training and for the assistant coach and fisio.
July 04, 2009 - 10:23am
Comments:
2
Date Joined:
12 Jun 2008
Last Active:
04 Sep 2014
There's hardly any point sharing your 6/7-star coaches with each other cos most coaches get variable attributes (equivalent to getting a 0 in data editor)

What I did was to set filters to determination > 12, discipline > 12 and motivating > 12 (up to you to toggle with the figures, depending on which attribute you find more important) and then set views to Coaching Attributes and you can cross refer to the Formulae given. Toggle between Coaching/Mental Attributes to see if the DDM is up to mark.

A pity is that I don't know if coaches' coaching attributes will actually increase with time as I noticed that they have CA/PA too. :(

Hope that helped!